Saltar al contenido principal
Pan y Hierro Nutrition and exercise with sources

Blog

Breakfast and intermittent fasting: what the trials show and what they do not

Breakfast and intermittent fasting: what the trials show and what they do not, and what can actually be claimed with current evidence.

Two opposite habits that pop culture treats as rules: eating breakfast “because it is the most important meal of the day” and fasting for a window of hours with the idea that this burns fat. The available trials support neither one as a rule. This article compares them with their numbers and their limits.

Let’s start with breakfast

A meta-analysis published in the BMJ in 2019, built on randomized trials from high-income countries, reviewed what happens to the weight and energy intake of people who eat breakfast versus those who do not [1]. It is 13 trials: seven measured weight and 10 measured energy intake.

Its conclusion is the one that circulated most, and it is worth reading carefully: eating breakfast was associated with an increase in weight and calorie intake, not a reduction. In the randomized trials the weight difference was just under half a kilo in favor of not eating breakfast, and daily energy intake was on the order of 260 kcal higher in those who did eat breakfast [1]. The trials did not always The review itself warns that you have to be careful about recommending breakfast for weight loss, because it could have the opposite effect [1]. And it states two limits that tend to get left out when it is cited:

  • All the included trials had a high or unclear risk of bias in at least one domain [1].
  • Follow-up was short: an average of seven weeks for weight and two weeks for energy intake [1].

The authors’ conclusion is that adding a breakfast “might not be a good strategy for weight loss,” whatever your previous habit is, and that better-quality trials are needed [1]. None of these studies evaluates populations outside high-income countries, so the conclusion does not transfer as is to other settings.

It is worth understanding the result, because it runs against intuition: skipping breakfast does not by itself produce weight loss. What is observed is that people who eat breakfast take in slightly more energy per day, and that difference is the one associated with weight [1]. The article did not prove a mechanism; it measured a difference.

Let’s start with breakfast: Comparison · Weight difference · Certainty
Comparison Weight difference Certainty
Alternate-day fasting vs continuous energy restriction A bit over 1 kg Moderate
Alternate-day fasting vs time-restricted eating A bit under 2 kg Moderate
Alternate-day fasting vs whole-day fasting A bit over 1 kg Moderate

In other words, alternate-day fasting is the only intermittent fasting strategy that beat continuous calorie restriction, and the last two differences are trivial according to the authors themselves: they are not advantages over counting calories, but advantages over other forms of fasting [2].

The trials of at least 24 weeks (17 of the 99) only showed benefit against eating without restriction, not against continuous restriction [2]. The benefit seems to live in eating less, not in the timing.

The article’s conclusion is that the differences between intermittent fasting strategies and continuous restriction are smaller, and that intermittent

Cochrane, which goes a step further

The 2026 Cochrane review of intermittent fasting in people with overweight or obesity is the most restrictive in its message. It includes 22 studies with 1,995 participants, all in outpatient settings and published between 2016 and 2024 [3].

Its most relevant results [3]:

  • Compared with usual dietary advice, intermittent fasting may make little or no difference in the percentage of weight lost from baseline: a difference of just under half a point (21 studies, 1,430 participants), with low certainty due to risk of bias [3].
  • Compared with receiving no advice or being on a waiting list, it probably makes little or no difference: around three and a half points (6 studies, 427 participants), with moderate certainty. These are percentage points of starting weight, not kilos: that is why the number looks big and the real weight in kg cannot be read off it [3].
  • Quality of life shows no relevant difference either, with low certainty versus dietary advice and very low certainty versus no advice [3].
  • On adverse effects the evidence is very uncertain: the estimate is compatible with both an increase and a reduction, and the authors are less certain [3].
  • None of the included studies collected data on satisfaction with the strategy, or on diabetes, or on overall comorbidity [3]. fasting offers benefits similar to continuous calorie restriction [2]. On these One scope detail worth keeping in mind: this Cochrane was done in people with overweight or obesity, not the general population, and all of its trials lasted 12 months or less [3]. The search is current to November 5, 2024, so it does not pick up anything later.

Where this fits with public health

The WHO fact sheet on healthy eating does not recommend intermittent fasting, nor does it make breakfast mandatory. Its four principles are adequacy, balance, moderation and variety, and its figures are expressed as proportions rather than timings: unrefined carbohydrates around 45-75% of energy, at least 25 g of fiber a day and at least 400 g of fruit and vegetables a day for people over 10 years old [4]. None of that depends on what time you eat.

What you take away

  • In randomized trials, eating breakfast was associated with slightly more weight (under half a kilo) and more calories (on the order of 260 kcal/day) than not eating breakfast, in short trials with high or unclear risk of bias [1].
  • Intermittent fasting reduces weight compared with eating without restriction, but against continuous calorie restriction the differences are smaller, on the order of 1 kg in the case of alternate-day fasting [2].
  • Cochrane concludes that intermittent fasting may make little or no difference compared with usual dietary advice, with low certainty, and probably little or no difference compared with no advice, with moderate certainty [3].
  • What none of these studies evaluates is satisfaction with the strategy [3].

None of these three articles is a weight loss plan, and the evidence gathered here does not support any promise about results. If you have diabetes, you are pregnant, or you take medication, the decision to fast belongs to your healthcare professional.

More from us: the sample menus, with the figures and sources from the Nutrition section, and the practical nutrition guide.

Related: 16:8 intermittent fasting, which breaks down the protocol hour by hour and what the meta-analyses show, and safe calorie deficit. numbers a correction was published in the journal itself (BMJ 2025;390:r1737), so the detailed figures are best read in the corrected version.

Now, intermittent fasting

Here the evidence is more recent and broader. A network meta-analysis published in the BMJ in 2025 included 99 randomized trials with 6,582 adults from different health conditions (720 healthy and 5,862 with pre-existing health problems) [2]. All intermittent fasting regimens and continuous energy restriction reduced weight compared with eating without restriction [2].

But the interesting comparison is a different one. You have to separate two comparators, because they do not say the same thing: agree with each other, especially on energy intake [1].

Related articles

Sources for this article (4) 4 references
  1. Sievert K, Hussain SM, Page MJ, Wang Y, Fisher JR, Ali S (2019) Effect of breakfast on weight and energy intake: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. BMJ 2019;364:l42. See source (opens in a new tab) DOI: 10.1136/bmj.l42 Metaanálisis de ensayos aleatorizados (desayuno, peso e ingesta energética) Licence: Artículo de acceso abierto (texto completo en PubMed Central, CC BY-NC 4.0). Se cita con enlace. Consulted:
  2. Semnani-Azad Z, Khan TA, Chiavaroli L, Chen V, Mann A, Frobisher A, et al. (2025) Intermittent fasting strategies and their effects on body weight and other cardiometabolic risk factors: systematic review and network meta-analysis of randomised clinical trials. BMJ 2025;389:e082007. See source (opens in a new tab) DOI: 10.1136/bmj-2024-082007 Metaanálisis en red de ensayos aleatorizados (estrategias de ayuno intermitente) Licence: Artículo de acceso abierto (texto completo en PubMed Central, CC BY-NC 4.0). Se cita con enlace. Consulted:
  3. Garegnani LI, Oltra G, Ivaldi D, Burgos MA, Andrenacci PJ, et al. (2026) Intermittent fasting for adults with overweight or obesity (CD015610). Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2026, Issue 2. Art. No.: CD015610. See source (opens in a new tab) DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD015610.pub2 Revisión sistemática Cochrane (ayuno intermitente en personas con sobrepeso u obesidad) Licence: Revisión de la Cochrane Library. Se cita con enlace; no se reproduce texto salvo cita breve verificable. Consulted:
  4. Organización Mundial de la Salud (OMS) (2026) Healthy diet — hoja de datos. Organización Mundial de la Salud (OMS). See source (opens in a new tab) Hoja de datos de la OMS (recomendaciones de salud pública) Licence: OMS: el contenido de esta web está disponible bajo licencia CC BY-NC-SA 3.0 IGO. Se cita con enlace. Consulted:

How to cite

Pan y Hierro (2026). Breakfast and intermittent fasting: what the trials show and what they do not. https://panyhierro.com/en/blog/breakfast-and-fasting/. Updated October 12, 2026.